Email Marketing vs. SEO: If you’re a marketer, chances are you have experience with both email marketing and SEO. Whether you’re new to the game or well-versed, you’re probably wondering which strategy makes more sense for your business.
In this post, I’ll dive into everything you need to know about email marketing vs. SEO. We’ll explore how marketers currently utilize both strategies and compare them against key marketing goals. Stay tuned for an enlightening discussion!
A Quick Refresher on Email Marketing and SEO
Email marketing is a highly effective strategy for reaching your audience. It involves sending targeted content to subscribers via email, including weekly update newsletters, promotional emails, and even personalized birthday messages.
This approach is not only flexible and cost-effective, but it also allows you to track important metrics such as click-through rate (CTR), open rate, and leads/conversions from emails. Enhance your marketing efforts with the power of email campaigns and engage your audience effectively.
image
Search engine optimization (SEO) is the key to increasing your website’s visibility in organic search results. To simplify, when my smoke detector starts annoyingly beeping, I immediately search for a step-by-step guide to replace its battery.
The fundamental elements of a successful SEO strategy include thorough keyword research, creating valuable, high-quality content, and ensuring that your website is easily accessible for search engine crawlers. Web analysts primarily focus on tracking important metrics such as sales, leads, and conversions. Enhancing these aspects can greatly improve your website’s performance and online presence.
image
Before contrasting these practices, let’s examine how marketers are effectively utilizing both approaches.
Email Marketing Vs. SEO – What are marketers saying?
According to our 2024 Marketing Strategy and Trends report, email marketing is the most widely utilized channel among marketers, with a usage rate of 33%. It is closely followed by website, blog, and SEO, which are leveraged by 32% of marketers.
Although email marketing is widely used, SEO offers the greatest return on investment (ROI), with email marketing closely following suit.
Marketers are showing no signs of relinquishing any channel. When we surveyed marketers about their top investment for 2024, website/blog/SEO claimed the second spot, closely followed by email marketing.
Delving deeper, a significant 48% of marketers expressed their intention to boost their investment in SEO in the upcoming year. Additionally, the majority (49%) plan to maintain their current level of investment in email marketing through 2024.
The surge in SEO investment can be attributed to Google’s inclusion of “experience” in the EAT framework (Expertise, Authority, and Trust) and the upcoming Search Generator Experience (SGE).
As a result of these developments, SEOs are likely adjusting their strategies to showcase their expertise and secure better rankings in the SERPs. This adaptation ensures they stay at the cutting edge of optimization practices.
Email Marketing vs SEO – A Comparison Against Marketing Goals
In the aforementioned report, we surveyed marketers regarding their aspirations for 2024. The primary objective is to elevate revenue/sales, closely followed by enhancing customer experience and expanding brand awareness to reach new audiences. Marketers also aim to boost engagement and drive traffic to their websites.
What better approach to evaluate the impact of email marketing and SEO on meeting these goals? Below, I will compare the two strategies and declare a winner for each of the top goals set by marketers.
1. SEO wins in increasing revenue/sales.
Return on investment (ROI) is directly related to marketers’ top goal for 2024: increased revenue/sales. Since marketers say SEO has the highest ROI of any channel they use, I’m handing this win to SEO.
2. Email marketing wins at improving customer experience.
Enhancing customer experience remains the primary objective for marketers in 2024. Personalization stands as a cornerstone of exceptional customer experience, and email proves to be an exceptional tool for achieving this goal. Thus, I proclaim email as the victor in this pursuit.
While it is true that you can tailor your website to cater to your audience’s needs and interests, the level of personalization achievable through email marketing surpasses that of any other medium. With email marketing, you have the ability to create specific segments for targeted personalization or even send individually customized emails on a customer-by-customer basis.
Consider this: Have you ever visited a website on your birthday and been greeted with a “happy birthday” message, personalized just for you? [Insert your name here], it’s unlikely. However, through email, you are much more likely to receive personalized messages from your favorite brands.
Let’s face it, the potential for personalized engagement is unparalleled with email marketing.
Expert tip: Enhance your email marketing strategies with HubSpot’s powerful tools. Personalize your emails for each subscriber by leveraging key characteristics such as lifestyle stage. Grab their attention with highly relevant subject lines, attachments, and compelling CTAs.
3. SEO wins for increasing brand awareness and reaching new audiences.
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) plays a crucial role in elevating brand awareness and expanding reach to new audiences. Surprisingly, approximately one in four websites experience an average SEO click-through rate ranging from 10% to 19%. Moreover, direct traffic and organic search remain the primary sources of website traffic, driving maximum engagement.
The reach of your channel expands significantly, as anyone searching the internet using keywords related to your business or offering has the potential to discover you. This translates into reaching a whole new audience.
On the other hand, your emails are exclusively sent to individuals who are already familiar with your business and have chosen to receive your updates. While it is possible to reach new people by purchasing email lists, I strongly advise against this practice. Instead, it is imperative to prioritize SEO as a means to connect with fresh audiences.
4. Email marketing wins at increasing engagement.
My objective is to enhance engagement in email marketing. While SEO can undoubtedly drive more traffic, it’s important to recognize that not all visitors may be qualified or ready to take the next step with your business.
Your email recipients, on the other hand, are qualified leads who have willingly subscribed to receive your emails because they have a genuine interest in what you have to offer. This inherent interest serves as a driving force, compelling them to become even more intrigued by your offerings. As a result, they are more likely to click through to your website and delve deeper into the information you have shared.
Email Marketing vs SEO: The Ultimate Decision
I understand the desire for a definitive answer, but unfortunately, I cannot provide that. The choice between email marketing and SEO depends on your specific marketing goals. If you aim to enhance brand awareness, putting more effort into SEO is recommended. Conversely, if building personal customer relationships is your priority, investing more time in email marketing is the way to go.
However, the most effective marketing strategies embrace a comprehensive approach. For instance, for a local business, prioritizing email marketing to inform the community about upcoming events, sales, or any business changes is crucial. Simultaneously, local SEO should not be neglected, as optimizing your Google My Business profile is essential to reach local searchers who are not yet familiar with your brand.
If you’re struggling to make a decision, consider this: Evaluate your specific goals and how email marketing and SEO excel in different areas. Determine which channel aligns best with your objectives and how it can support your overall marketing efforts.
Regardless of your choice, both email marketing and SEO have stood the test of time and can drive the growth you seek.